Skip to main
Good Guys Pizza
  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Specialty Pizzas
  • Pizza
  • Calzones
  • Appetizers
  • Chicken Wings
  • Wraps
  • Toasted Crunch Wraps
  • Subs
  • Quesadillas
  • Salads
  • Sides & Extras
  • Drinks & Desserts
  • Lovin Nature with Cynthia
  • Slices - All Days 11am - 4pm
  • Monday 2 for $25 Sub Special
  • Tuesday Pick-Up Special
  • Wednesday Wings Special

Good Guys Pizza Menu

3313 Chili Ave Ste 2, Rochester, NY

3313 Chili Ave Ste 2, Rochester, NY

·

  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Specialty Pizzas
  • Pizza
  • Calzones
  • Appetizers
  • Chicken Wings
  • Wraps
  • Toasted Crunch Wraps
  • Subs
  • Quesadillas
  • Salads
  • Sides & Extras
  • Drinks & Desserts
  • Lovin Nature with Cynthia
  • Slices - All Days 11am - 4pm
  • Monday 2 for $25 Sub Special
  • Tuesday Pick-Up Special
  • Wednesday Wings Special

Most ordered

  • Single Wings (10).

    Single Wings (10)

    $14.99

  • Large Cheese.

    Large Cheese

    $19.49

  • Medium Cheese.

    Medium Cheese

    $15.99

  • Extra Large Cheese.

    Extra Large Cheese

    $21.99

  • Sheet Cheese.

    Sheet Cheese

    $30.49

  • Bucket Wings (40).

    Bucket Wings (40)

    $58.99+

  • Large Cheese.

    Large Cheese

    $13.99

  • Beer-Battered Fish Fry.

    Beer-Battered Fish Fry

    $16.99

Specialty Pizzas

Our signature pies, available Medium or Large

Good Guys Pizza Medium

$21.49

Buffalo chicken pizza plus ham & crumbled bacon

Good Guys Pizza Medium.

Meat Lovers Pizza Medium

$20.99

Sausage, pepperoni, ham, and crumbled bacon

Meat Lovers Pizza Medium.

Veggie Lovers Pizza Medium

$20.99+

Mushrooms, onions, green peppers & broccoli

Veggie Lovers Pizza Medium.

Pepperoni Lovers Pizza Medium

$18.99

A generous mix of traditional and cup-n-curl pepperoni

Pepperoni Lovers Pizza Medium.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Medium

$19.49

Our thin crust pizza with mild or hot wing sauce, mozzarella cheese & chicken tenders

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Medium.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Large

$23.99

Our thin crust pizza with mild or hot wing sauce, mozzarella cheese & chicken tenders

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Large.

Good Guys Pizza Large

$26.99

Buffalo chicken pizza plus ham & crumbled bacon

Meat Lovers Pizza Large

$25.99

Buffalo chicken pizza plus ham & crumbled bacon

Pepperoni Lovers Pizza Large

$23.49

A generous mix of traditional and cup-n-curl pepperoni

Pepperoni Lovers Pizza Large.

Veggie Lovers Pizza Large

$25.99+

Mushrooms, onions, green peppers & broccoli

Veggie Lovers Pizza Large.

Breakfast Meat Lovers Medium

$21.49

Breakfast pizza plus sausage, ham and bacon

Breakfast Veggie Lovers Medium

$21.49

Breakfast pizza plus mushroom, onion, green peppers

Egg & Cheese Medium

$18.99

Breakfast Meat Lovers Large

$26.99

Breakfast pizza plus sausage, ham and bacon

Breakfast Veggie Lovers Large

$26.99

Large breakfast pizza plus mushroom, onion and green peppers

Egg & Cheese Large

$23.99

Pizza

Hand-tossed pizza in Traditional, White Garlic, Pink, Thick or Thin style

Quesa-Pizza

$5.99

A small pizza on a quesadilla shell with marinara and mozzarella (4pc)

Medium Cheese

$15.99

Our classic pizza topped with savory sauce and plenty of perfectly melted cheese, baked to hot, bubbly perfection. Cut into 8 slices

Medium Cheese.

Large Cheese

$19.49

Hand-tossed pizza topped with pizza sauce and melted mozzarella. Choose your crust style and favorite toppings.

Large Cheese.

Large NY Style- Delivery

$19.49

Our large NY-style cheese pizza. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Large NY Style Pick Up Only

$16.99

Our large NY-style cheese pizza at a special everyday pickup price. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Extra Large Cheese

$21.99

Our extra-large pizza with classic red sauce and melted mozzarella, baked to a golden finish. Enjoy it as a cheese pizza or add your favorite toppings. Pictured with sausage and mushrooms; toppings cost extra.

Extra Large Cheese.

Sheet Cheese

$30.49

A large rectangular pizza topped with mozzarella cheese, 30 slices.

Sheet Cheese.

Calzones

All calzones include ricotta, mozzarella and romano with a side of marinara

Basic Zone Calzone

$12.99+

A stuffed calzone with your choice of one topping, plus ricotta, mozzarella and romano. Served with a side of marinara.

Basic Zone Calzone.

Meat Zone Calzone

$15.99

A stuffed calzone with steak, sausage, meatball and pepperoni, plus ricotta, mozzarella and romano. Served with a side of marinara.

Meat Zone Calzone.

Veggie Zone Calzone

$15.99

A stuffed calzone with broccoli, onions, mushrooms and peppers, plus ricotta, mozzarella and romano. Served with a side of marinara.

Veggie Zone Calzone.

Good Guy Zone Calzone

$15.99+

A stuffed calzone with steak, sausage, onions and sweet & hot peppers, plus ricotta, mozzarella and romano. Served with a side of marinara.

Good Guy Zone Calzone.

Appetizers

Crowd-pleasing starters to share

Pizza Logs (5)

$8.99

With marinara

Mexican Fiestadas

$5.25

With buffalo hot sauce

Mexican Fiestadas.

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

$7.99

With marinara

Mozzarella Sticks (6).

Chicken Finger Dinner (4)

$15.99

With fries, bleu cheese, sweet and sour sauce

Chicken Finger Dinner (4).

Onion Rings

$6.99

Thick-cut onion rings fried to a crispy golden brown.

Onion Rings.

Loaded Fries

$12.99

1lb of fries topped with cheddar and bacon

Loaded Fries.

French Fries

$4.99+

French Fries.

Fried Mushrooms

$7.99

Served with bleu cheese

Fried Mushrooms.

Potato Skins (4)

$9.99

With sour cream

Potato Skins (4).

Cheesy Breadsticks

$9.49

With marinara

Cheesy Breadsticks.

Mac N' Cheese Wedges

$7.99

With sweet & sour sauce

Mac N' Cheese Wedges.

Garlic Bread

$5.99

With marinara

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$6.99

With marinara

Beer-Battered Fish Fry

$16.99

Served with french fries, lemon, coleslaw, fresh roll and tartar sauce. Available every day!

Beer-Battered Fish Fry.

Spicy Potato Wedges Small

$5.99+

Buffalo Chicken Logs (5)

$8.99

Plain or tossed with any wing sauce of your choice

Fried Pickles (5)

$8.99

With ranch dressing

Chicken Fingers (4)

$13.99

With bleu cheese and country sweet

Chicken Wings

All wings come with a side of bleu cheese and celery

Single Wings (10)

$14.99

Crispy, juicy bone-in wings tossed in your choice of flavorful sauce. A classic favorite with the perfect combination of crunch and tenderness. Comes with a side of celery and blue cheese.

Single Wings (10).

Single Boneless Wings (10)

$14.49

Tender, juicy boneless chicken bites cooked until golden and tossed in your choice of delicious sauce. Easy to eat and packed with flavor! Served with a side of celery and blue cheese.

Single Boneless Wings (10).

Bucket Wings (40)

$58.99+

40 wings served with bleu cheese and celery. Regular, Boneless or Breaded - mix and match (10each)

Bucket Wings (40).

Single Breaded Wings (10)

$15.99

Freshly breaded chicken wings in our flour spice combination. Served PLAIN with your choice of sauce on the side to keep them crispy! If you would like them tossed in sauce please let us know. Served with bleu cheese and celery

Single Breaded Wings (10).

Wraps

All wraps include lettuce, tomatoes, mayo and shredded cheddar

BLT Wrap

$11.49

With mayo, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and shredded cheddar

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$11.49

With mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, and shredded cheddar. Served in mild or hot sauce

Chicken BLT Wrap

$11.49

Crispy chicken fingers with mayo, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and shredded cheddar

Make Your Own Wrap

$11.49+

Use any sub or pizza topping. Includes 1 meat and 2 toppings

Sweet and Spicy Wrap

$11.49

Chicken with S & S sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo and shredded cheddar

Chicken Salad Wrap

$11.49

Chicken salad, lettuce, tomatoes, and shredded cheddar

Toasted Crunch Wraps

Griddle-toasted wraps with a crispy crunch

Chicken Finger Crunch Wrap

$12.99

A toasted crunch wrap with crispy chicken fingers, your choice of sauce and cheese.

Meatball Crunch Wrap

$12.99

A toasted crunch wrap with meatballs, marinara and your choice of cheese.

Steak Crunch Wrap

$12.99

A toasted crunch wrap with steak, any two toppings and your choice of cheese.

Tuna Melt Crunch Wrap

$12.99

A toasted crunch wrap with tuna salad, cheddar cheese and your choice of onions, green or hot peppers.

Chicken Salad Crunch Wrap

$12.99

A toasted crunch wrap with chicken salad and your choice of cheese.

Subs

American Assorted Large

$14.25

An assortment of American-style deli meats and cheese on a fresh sub roll, served cold with your choice of toppings.

Italian Assorted Large

$15.99

Ham, pepperoni, hard salami with cheese of your choice

Italian Assorted Large.

BLT Sub Large

$15.99

Served with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise.

Chicken Cordon Bleu Large

$15.99

Chicken fingers with ham, Swiss and bleu cheese

Chicken Cordon Bleu Large.

Chicken Finger Sub Large

$15.99

Chicken fingers served with Buffalo mild sauce, topped with mozzarella on a toasted roll

Chicken Parmesan Sub Large

$15.99

Chicken covered in marinara, mozzarella, parmesan, and oregano.

Fish Sub Large

$15.99

Comes with tartar sauce & American cheese

Good Guy Sub Large

$15.99

A chicken finger sub served with mild sauce, bacon, ham and mozzarella cheese

Ham Large

$14.25

Sliced ham layered on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Ham Large.

Meatball Sub Large

$15.99

Served with mozzarella, marinara, parmesan & oregano.

Pizza Sub Large

$15.99+

Split sub roll that's Toasted served with mozzarella, marinara & pizza toppings of your choice.

Pizza Sub Large.

Steak Bomber Large

$15.99

Grilled shaved steak on a toasted sub roll with your choice of cheese and toppings. Add meat hot sauce on the side.

Steak Bomber Large.

Tuna Large

$14.25

House tuna salad on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Tuna Melt Large

$15.99

With American cheese

Turkey Club Large

$15.99

Roasted turkey with bacon and mozzarella

Turkey Large

$14.25

Sliced turkey breast piled on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Chicken Salad Sub Cold

$14.25

House-made chicken salad on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Chicken Salad-Hot Sub

$15.99

House-made chicken salad on a toasted sub roll with your choice of cheese and fresh toppings.

American Assorted Regular

$11.49

An assortment of American-style deli meats and cheese on a fresh sub roll, served cold with your choice of toppings.

Italian Assorted Regular

$12.99

Pepperoni, hard salami, ham and choice of cheese.

BLT Sub Regular

$12.99

Served with Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise.

Chicken Cordon Bleu Regular

$12.99

Chicken fingers with ham, Swiss and bleu cheese

Chicken Finger Sub Regular

$12.99

Chicken fingers served with Buffalo mild sauce, topped with mozzarella on a toasted roll

Chicken Parmesan Sub Regular

$12.99

Chicken covered in marinara, mozzarella, parmesan, and oregano.

Good Guy Sub Regular

$12.99

A chicken finger sub served with mild sauce, bacon, ham and mozzarella cheese

Ham Regular

$11.49

Sliced ham layered on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Meatball Sub Regular

$12.99

Served with mozzarella, marinara, parmesan & oregano.

Pizza Sub Regular

$12.99+

Split sub roll that's Toasted served with mozzarella, marinara & pizza toppings of your choice.

Pizza Sub Regular.

Steak Bomber Regular

$12.99

Grilled shaved steak on a toasted sub roll with your choice of cheese and toppings. Add meat hot sauce on the side.

Tuna Melt Regular

$12.99

With American cheese

Tuna Regular

$11.49

House tuna salad on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Turkey Club Regular

$12.99

Roasted turkey with bacon and mozzarella

Turkey Regular

$11.49

Sliced turkey breast piled on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Chicken Salad-Cold Sub

$11.49

House-made chicken salad on a fresh sub roll with your choice of toppings, served cold.

Chicken Salad-Hot Sub

$12.99

House-made chicken salad on a toasted sub roll with your choice of cheese and fresh toppings.

Quesadillas

Grilled flour tortillas served with sour cream and salsa

Regular Cheese Quesadilla

$6.99+

A grilled flour tortilla stuffed with melted cheese, served with sour cream and salsa.

Regular Cheese Quesadilla.

Regular Chicken Quesadilla

$8.99+

A grilled flour tortilla loaded with seasoned chicken and melted cheese, served with sour cream and salsa.

Regular Chicken Quesadilla.

Regular Steak Quesadilla

$8.99+

A grilled flour tortilla filled with seasoned steak and melted cheese, served with sour cream and salsa.

Salads

All salads come with two dressings; side salad comes with one

Chicken Finger Salad

$13.49

A crisp garden salad topped with breaded chicken fingers, tomatoes, onions and croutons over lettuce.

Chicken Finger Salad.

Chef Salad

$12.99

A generous garden salad topped with sliced ham and turkey, tomatoes, onions, lettuce and croutons.

Side Salad

$5.50

A crisp garden salad of lettuce, tomatoes and onions with croutons. Comes with one dressing.

Garden Salad

$9.99

A fresh salad of crisp lettuce, tomatoes and onions topped with croutons.

Sides & Extras

Side of Bleu Cheese

$0.75

An extra side of our house bleu cheese dressing for dipping.

Side Dressing

$0.75

Side of Pizza Sauce

$0.75

An extra cup of our signature marinara pizza sauce.

Side Wing Sauce

$0.75

Tartar Sauce

$0.75

A side of tartar sauce, perfect with our fish fry.

Coleslaw

$1.50

A creamy, crunchy side of house coleslaw.

Meat Hot Sauce

$1.00

A side of our zesty meat hot sauce for steak subs and more.

Sour Cream

$1.00

A side of sour cream.

A1 Steak Sauce

$1.00

A side of A1 steak sauce.

1 Pound of Dough

$2.25

Side of Topping

$1.50

Plates/Napkins

$1.50

Extra Celery

$1.00

T Shirt

$20.00

Chips

$1.00

A single-serve bag of potato chips.

Drinks & Desserts

Fresh Baked Cookie

$2.31

Choose from Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Raisin

Fresh Baked Cookie.

2-Liter Soda

$3.75

A chilled 2-liter bottle of soda in your choice of flavor.

20oz Soda

$2.56

A chilled 20 oz bottle of soda in your choice of flavor.

Funnel Fries

$6.49+

Just like funnel cake, served in powdered sugar

Funnel Fries.

Lovin Nature with Cynthia

An Introduction to the Universal Laws

$10.00

Good Guys feeds the body. Lovin Nature feeds the soul! 🍕🌿 Written by Good Guys co-owner and local author Cynthia Unger, this short, inspiring book introduces the Universal Laws and offers simple ways to bring more positivity, gratitude, and intention into everyday life.

An Introduction to the Universal Laws.

Lovin Nature Through Awareness and Reflection

$15.00

Good Guys feeds the body. Lovin Nature feeds the soul! 🍕🌿 Join Good Guys co-owner and local author Cynthia Unger on a personal journey through nature, mindfulness, self-love, and the everyday magic found through awareness and reflection. Through the lens of Cynthia’s own experiences, this book invites you to slow down, reconnect, and reflect. It is a story of learning, growth, and the transformative power of aligning with life’s natural rhythms and Universal Laws.

Lovin Nature Through Awareness and Reflection.

Lovin Nature Through Awareness and Reflection- Hardcover

$25.00

Good Guys feeds the body. Lovin Nature feeds the soul! 🍕🌿 Join Good Guys co-owner and local author Cynthia Unger on a personal journey through nature, mindfulness, self-love, and the everyday magic found through awareness and reflection. Through the lens of Cynthia’s own experiences, this book invites you to slow down, reconnect, and reflect. It is a story of learning, growth, and the transformative power of aligning with life’s natural rhythms and Universal Laws.

Lovin Nature Through Awareness and Reflection- Hardcover.

Mug

$15.00

A selection of nature inspired mugs. Please stop in store to shop or search Lovin Nature Prints for more options.

Slices - All Days 11am - 4pm

11 AM - 4 PM

Slice Cheese Pepperoni

$4.62

Slice Cheese Pepperoni.

2 Slices & 20 oz

$10.18

Cheese, Pepperoni Lover's, White Cheese and White Bacon available every day. Please add your choice to the special requests box. DAILY SPECIALS: Monday - Buffalo Chicken Tuesday - Pepperoni Sausage Wednesday - Buffalo Chicken Thursday - Pepperoni Bacon Friday - Buffalo Chicken

2 Slices & 20 oz.

1 Slice& 20 oz

$7.17

Cheese, Pepperoni Lover's, White Cheese and White Bacon available every day. Please add your choice to the special requests box. DAILY SPECIALS: Monday - Buffalo Chicken Tuesday - Pepperoni Sausage Wednesday - Buffalo Chicken Thursday - Pepperoni Bacon Friday - Buffalo Chicken

1 Slice& 20 oz.

Side Bleu/Ranch

$0.75

Monday 2 for $25 Sub Special

Mon

2 Large Subs for $25

$25.00+

Choose any two large 12-inch subs for $25. Available Mondays only.

Tuesday Pick-Up Special

Tue

Large Cheese

$13.99

Large Cheese.

Wednesday Wings Special

Wed

Single Wings (10)

$10.00

Crispy, juicy bone-in wings tossed in your choice of flavorful sauce. A classic favorite with the perfect combination of crunch and tenderness. Comes with a side of celery and blue cheese.

Single Wings (10).

Bucket Wings (40)

$40.00+

40 wings served with bleu cheese and celery

Single Breaded Wings (10)

$10.00

Freshly breaded chicken wings in our flour spice combination. Served PLAIN with your choice of sauce on the side to keep them crispy! If you would like them tossed in sauce please let us know. Served with bleu cheese and celery

Single Breaded Wings (10).

Single Boneless Wings (10)

$10.00

Tender, juicy boneless chicken bites cooked until golden and tossed in your choice of delicious sauce. Easy to eat and packed with flavor! Served with a side of celery and blue cheese.

Single Boneless Wings (10).
Chili

Menu

Catering

Our Story

Gift Cards

We're Hiring

Specials

Gallery & Community

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Unger Family Ventures LLC 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner